This series of videos depicts a hypothetical orientation meeting between a term supervisor and JMO in a rural hospital. The videos demonstrate a number of elements of the 7 principles. Scene 1 particularly demonstrates principles 1 and 2. Scene 2 demonstrates principles 3,4 and 5.
The JMO's circumstances present challenges for both parties. The JMO has been seconded from his parent hospital in a metropolitan setting to the rural hospital, half way into the term, to fill an urgent vacancy. Unbeknown to the supervisor, the JMO has several specific concerns. Firstly, he has discovered that he has been rostered as the after hours medical officer on day two of his secondment, which causes him anxiety. Secondly, he is disappointed that he was notified of the secondment on the day he returned to work after his honeymoon. Thirdly, he is disgruntled that he was uprooted from a surgical term in his parent hospital to work with the geriatrics team, as he aspires to enter surgical training.
Scenes 1a and 1b show two contrasting versions of the introductory part of the meeting.
At a basic level, the conversation starts well. The room is well set up with supervisor and JMO sitting comfortably and facing each other. The table will be useful in this meeting if the two wish to go through documents, however some people might prefer two chairs, alone. Both parties are polite although somewhat reserved. The supervisor introduces himself as the director of training, thanks the JMO for coming, explains the purpose of the meeting and signposts what will be covered. These are effective in the early part of supervision conversations. While he preempts the JMO's surprise at being seconded mid-term "This must have been a little bit of a shock for you", he does not explore this further or seek to provide any further background on himself or find out about the JMO, as an individual (he may plan to do so later in the discussion).
The supervisor is outwardly more friendly. After signposting the conversation, he provides some background on himself and the invites the JMO to do the same. This leads to the JMO revealing his first concern (being away from his new spouse). In this regard the JMO is open and forthcoming without overt anger. With the advantage of this knowledge, the supervisor can and does express empathy, by acknowledging the JMO's commitment, apologising for the disruption to his life and thanking him. This demonstrates concern for the JMO as an individual.
Charter elements featured
1. Demonstrate respect
#1 be friendly and interested in others
#2 interact politely and acknowledge others' effort and contribution
#4 remain composed when frustrated or stressed
2. Promote diversity and wellbeing
#5 show concern for others
Scenes 2a and 2b show two contrasting versions of part of the meeting in which the roster is discussed.
In this scene, the supervisor attempts to clarify the JMO's understanding of the roster, and presumably resolve any concerns. However, both the JMO's and supervisor's communication is inadequate.
The JMO makes ambiguous unassertive references to his concern about being rostered on overtime on his second day.
Supervisor "Have you looked over your roster?"
JMO "Yes, that was interesting!"
Supervisor "Interesting - Good! - Does it make sense?"
JMO - It all makes sense
The supervisor overlooks an opportunity to directly pick up on these cues (E.g. "Interesting - what do you mean by that?"). Rather, he indirectly responds to the JMO's concern by highlighting that the local team are very supportive.
"I was surprised to see I was rostered on overtime on my second day, so I would like to get a handle on that. But otherwise its OK"
"They have thrown you in the deep end, have they? ..It is being thrown in the deep end but you will get on with it, you will be absolutely fine"
In this version, both parties use more direct language which succeeds in flagging the roster as a concern.
JMO: "Did you know they have me on overtime on my second day?"
Supervisor: "I didn't know that - that must have been a surprise"
Unfortunately, the JMO then risks generating conflict by layering his concern with a judgement about the roster manager:
JMO: "It just seems a bit premature - I won't say ill thought out - just a bit premature to be solely responsible on my second day"
It is unnecessary and counterproductive to blame others. One should focus on issues and personal needs. A cleaner more objective approach would have been to simply state the issue he is concerned about, why it concerns him and what he really needs. Some people call this a 3 step "I" statement
1. I am rostered on an overtime shift tomorrow on my second day in this hospital.
2. I am concerned that I am unfamiliar with this hospital processes and local teams as I know from previous experience that patients can deteriorate after hours.
3. I don't feel I can do this shift until I feel more comfortable to work independently, in this hospital.
Fortunately, the supervisor demonstrates effective communication by responding to the JMO's clue with a probe: "Are there any specific concerns you have about that on-call shift?"
These scenarios demonstrate how listening and asking enable people to understand one another's perspectives and concerns. People are reluctant to be open with others who are unfamiliar to them, especially if a power gradient exists. Picking up on non verbal and verbal cues with an enquiry invites the other person to discuss issues. This is a very effective strategy for supervisors, who may be unaware of, or underestimate, the impact of the power gradient between them and JMOs. Fortunately, in this these videos, the supervisor circumvented the need for further assertiveness on the part of the JMO, by listening, asking and responding the JMO's concerns.
Click here for more tips on assertiveness and an example of how it could have been used in these videos.
Charter elements featured
3. Ensure patients and staff are safe
#10 Clarify when unclear or concerned about advice
#11 Practice within role and consult appropriately
. Collaborate to create an open, safe and empowering learning environment
#13 Clarify roles, priorities and expectations, regarding communication and consultation.
#14 Show initiative, promote independence and offer support
5. Monitor and manage JMOs' work environment
#17 Monitor workloads and seek and or provide support to manage them
#19 Raise concerns (and encourage others to do the same) if any aspect of one's work impacts negatively on productivity, wellbeing, or career progression.